Teacher Union Bargaining Cases Move Forward Print E-mail
By Audrey Spalding   
Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Documents from the Springfield School District court case:

The lawsuit, filed on June 2, 2009

The circuit court ruling, handed down on Sept. 10

Documents from the Bayless School District lawsuit:

The lawsuit, and response from the district

The district's bargaining agreement

A district affiliate of the majority state teacher union, the Missouri National Education Association (MNEA), has appealed a state judge's ruling that public school teachers can choose whether to be represented by one union, several, or none. Most public school districts in the state negotiate with only one teachers' union, but a select few, such as the Springfield, Brentwood, and Bayless school districts, allow non-exclusive teacher–school district negotiations.

The issue of teacher union representation came to a head at the Springfield School District when the Springfield National Education Association (SNEA) filed suit on June 2.

The SNEA argued against a district policy that allowed teachers to vote first for either single, multiple, or no representation, and then later to vote on which union (or unions) would represent them in negotiations with the school district. In court, Sally Barker, an attorney for the SNEA, argued that such a voting system represented a "false choice," and that collective representation was traditionally understood to be done by a single union.

The Greene County Circuit Court allowed the district policy. In his ruling, Judge Michael Cordonnier wrote that the Article I, Section 29, of the Missouri Constitution provides for multiple representation with the following language: "That employees shall have the right to organize and to bargain collectively through representatives of their own choosing."

“The word ‘representatives’ in Section 29 is unambiguous, plural, and must be read to include the possibility of more than one representative,” Cordonnier wrote.

On Oct. 20, the SNEA filed a notice of appeal with the Southern District Court of Appeals. The appeal itself hasn't been filed with the court, said Sandra Skinner, the court clerk. The filing could come as late as the end of January, she said.

BAYLESS

Another teacher union lawsuit, this one on the behalf of the Bayless National Education Association (BNEA), has been scheduled for trial on Dec. 11 at the Saint Louis County circuit court. According to court documents, Barker will be representing the BNEA.

The BNEA's suit alleges that the school district has violated Article 1, section 29, of the Missouri Constitution by refusing to recognize the BNEA as the exclusive bargaining representative of the district's teachers, or agreeing to let teachers vote on the matter.

Under the district's policy adopted in Feb. 2009, "Bayless Working Together," teachers in each school building nominate and vote for two representatives and one alternate, regardless of union affiliation. In its response to the lawsuit, the district wrote that it prefers to keep the current collective bargaining arrangement in place.

At trial, Barker will likely argue that the district's bargaining policy isn't a legitimate form of collective bargaining and violates the state constitution.

In the lawsuit filed on behalf of the BNEA, Barker wrote that the district's collective bargaining policies "violate Plantiff's right to engage in collective bargaining within the meaning of Article I, Section 29."

 

 
 

FOLLOW US @ Sign up for the Show-Me Institutes RSS feedFollow the Show-Me Institute on FacebookFollow the Show-Me Institute on TwitterWatch the Show-Me Instititute on You Tube

STAY INFORMED

Signup here:

EVENT VIDEO

JavaScript is disabled!
To display this content, you need a JavaScript capable browser.

More videos...

AUDIO

KWMU: Stokes Talks About The Benefits Of Privatization
March 25, 2014

Show Me's David Stokes talks about the value of privatization on St. Louis's public radio station. Listen to the conversation.



VISIT OUR OTHER SITES!

Show-Me Daily Blog data-button
Show-Me Living Show-Me Book Club

4512 West Pine Blvd.
Saint Louis, MO 63108

Phone: (314) 454-0647
Fax: (314) 454-0667
info@showmeinstitute.org